TL;DR

• Employer reputation now shapes the entire talent journey. 75% of job seekers research a company’s brand before applying (Indeed survey via Withe).
• Negative brand cues cost real money: 69% of candidates would reject an offer from a company with a poor reputation (same source).
• Early-warning signs hide in your data: Review‑site ratings, offer‑acceptance rates, social sentiment, employee‑survey scores, and referral volumes all trend downward months before hiring stalls or churn spikes.
• Track these five metrics to catch trouble early—and follow the fixes below to reverse course. A proactive “brand‑pulse” routine can lower turnover by up to 28% and cut cost‑per‑hire in half.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Why Brand Vigilance Matters
3. 5 Data Signals Your Employer Reputation Is Slipping
4. In Summary
5. FAQs
6. Get Help From Talivity

Introduction

Recruiting happens in public. Glassdoor reviews, LinkedIn posts, even TikTok “day‑in‑the‑life” videos shape perception long before a recruiter ever hits send. When that perception sours, the impact is immediate: fewer applicants, lower offer‑acceptance, higher turnover, and rising labor costs.

“Your employer brand is a living balance sheet—when trust declines, you pay interest on every hire.” — Mona Tawakali, Chief Strategy Officer, Talivity

Yet most organizations don’t track employer brand health with the same rigor they apply to sales or NPS. This article shows you how to run a quick brand pulse check using five objective data signals that flag reputation risk while there’s still time to fix it.

Why Brand Vigilance Matters

Pro Tip: Feed these KPIs into a simple dashboard (Power BI, Looker Studio) and set alerts for ±10% moves over a 30‑day window.

5 Data Signals Your Employer Reputation Is Slipping

1. Review‑Site Rating Trend (Glassdoor, Indeed, Comparably)

Employer-review platforms are often the first touchpoint a prospect encounters after seeing your job ad or recruiter message. These crowdsourced ratings function like a credit score for your culture, compressing anonymous stories, sentiment trends, and leadership credibility into a single number. 

Because review sites refresh continually, even a quarter-point slide can surface in candidate research within days, discouraging applications and triggering follow-up questions from investors and journalists.

Monitoring this publicly visible metric lets you spot brewing perception issues long before they erode pipeline quality or seep into analyst reports.

• Red flag: Overall rating falls ≥ 0.2 points in a quarter or a surge in “Cons” mentioning leadership transparency or layoffs.
• Why it matters: Glassdoor studies show ratings continue to erode 180 days after a layoff event, dragging CEO approval down 16 pts (Glassdoor Workplace Trends 2024).

“Think of your employer rating like a credit score—every drop costs you. One star down on Glassdoor? Expect up to 30% fewer applicants.” — Kara Somsen, VP of Strategic Consulting, Talivity

• Fix it:
  1. Acknowledge feedback publicly within 72 hrs.
  2. Extract top‑3 themes and publish a 30‑day action plan.
  3. Prompt balanced reviews from new hires and alumni networks.

2. Offer‑to‑Acceptance Ratio

Compensation can get you onto a finalist list, but the ratio of offers accepted reveals whether candidates believe your story once they see the full picture.

Falling acceptance rates often materialize two or three recruiting cycles before Glassdoor scores drop, making this an early internal indicator that external brand perception is misaligned with lived reality.

A shrinking accept‑rate also inflates cost‑per‑hire: recruiters must court more finalists, raise offers, and extend closing timelines, burning budget and frustrating hiring managers.

• Red flag: Acceptances drop below 60% or decline > 10% YoY for key roles.
• Why it matters: Candidates double‑check reviews after receiving an offer—last‑minute reputation concerns often outweigh comp.

“Salary gets you on the shortlist. Reputation often seals the deal.” — Jodie Cherry Roth, Senior Director of Strategic Consulting, Talivity

• Fix it:
  • Create a branded decision kit: role‑preview video, benefits explainer, DEI stats.
  • Include future peers in final‑round calls; authenticity beats polish.

3. Social & Owned‑Channel Engagement

Your LinkedIn feed, careers site, and even TikTok channel act as 24/7 billboards for life at your company. Engagement rates reveal whether the narrative resonates or rings hollow.

Because algorithms reward interaction, a decline in likes, comments, and shares doesn’t just signal waning interest, it actively suppresses future reach, creating a visibility death spiral that paid ads struggle to overcome.

Sustained engagement keeps your employer value proposition top‑of‑mind for passive candidates and amplifies good news faster than any press release.

• Red flag: Employer‑brand post engagement (likes + comments ÷ followers) drops below 1% on LinkedIn or sentiment skews negative for two consecutive weeks (Sprout Social Benchmarks 2025).
• Fix it:
  • Rotate in employee‑generated content: day‑in‑the‑life Reels, takeover stories.
  • Use social‑listening tools (Sprout, Brandwatch) to track sentiment; reply to critical comments within 24 hrs.

4. Internal eNPS / Pulse‑Survey Scores

External perception ultimately stems from internal reality. Employee Net Promoter Score (eNPS) and quick‑pulse surveys gauge trust, psychological safety, and purpose before those feelings leak to Glassdoor or social media.

Because these surveys are confidential, they surface issues employees might never raise in a town‑hall—everything from workload imbalance to leadership skepticism.

A double‑digit eNPS slide correlates strongly with voluntary turnover and referral slowdowns, making it a powerful predictor for both flight risk and reputation drag.

• Red flag: eNPS slips into negative territory or drops 10 pts in a quarter.
• Why it matters: Internal sentiment leaks externally via reviews and referrals, often preceding attrition spikes.

“Employee sentiment is the canary in the coal mine; ignore it and you’ll be staffing exits instead of growth.” — Bruce Carey, VP of Brand and Creative, Talivity

• Fix it:
  • Share results transparently with a time‑bound improvement roadmap.
  • Empower cross‑functional “culture squads” to co‑design quick wins (flexible schedules, recognition programs).

5. Referral Rate & Quality

Employees only stake their personal reputations on referrals when they genuinely believe in the workplace. A falling share of referral hires or a spike in referred‑candidate withdrawals signals that insiders are losing confidence—often before they exit themselves.

Because referrals convert faster and cost less than any other source, a declining referral pipeline forces you to spend more on paid channels, stretching recruiting budgets and elongating time‑to‑hire.

Treat this metric as both a trust barometer and a spend‑efficiency lever.

• Red flag: Employee referrals <15% of total hires and referred candidates withdraw at higher‑than‑average rates.
• Fix it:
  • Refresh referral incentives with tiered rewards.
  • Spotlight referral success stories in all‑hands and social channels.
  • Survey employees who stopped referring to uncover hidden friction.

In Summary

To keep your employer brand thriving:

• Monitor the five signals monthly. Automate alerts and visualize in a shared dashboard.
• Respond fast and visibly. Public acknowledgments and small policy tweaks can arrest negative momentum.
• Benchmark quarterly. Treat employer reputation like revenue—measured, owned, and continuously improved.

FAQs

Q: How often should we run a Brand Pulse Check?

A: High-velocity companies should conduct a pulse check every calendar month, syncing the review with existing HR analytics meetings to minimize overhead.

This cadence captures brand sentiment swings quickly—especially after earnings calls, product launches, or macro-events such as layoffs that can jolt perception overnight.

If you operate in a more stable, low-turnover environment, a quarterly review generally suffices, provided you set automated alerts that flag material shifts between checkpoints.

The key is consistency: choose a rhythm, assign ownership, and publish the findings so stakeholders can see trends over time instead of isolated snapshots.

Q: What tools do we need?

A: Start with the platforms you already own: your ATS for offer‑flow data, Glassdoor/Indeed employer dashboards for review analytics, and LinkedIn Page Insights for social engagement.

Layer in an employee‑survey solution (Culture Amp, Lattice, Peakon) to capture eNPS and pulse feedback. For sentiment monitoring, affordable options like Sprout Social or Brandwatch plug into existing channels and surface real‑time alerts.

Finally, pull everything into a lightweight BI tool—Google Looker Studio or Microsoft Power BI—to build a single view of brand health that automatically refreshes.

Total out‑of‑pocket can be under $5K per year if you leverage freemium tiers and existing licenses.

Q: Our Glassdoor score is low but stable—should we worry?

A: A flat line at a subpar rating is like a low credit score you never improve—it quietly narrows your opportunities. Research from SHRM shows that companies with ratings below 3.5 attract 47 % fewer qualified applicants, inflating cost‑per‑hire by roughly one‑third.

Even if the score isn’t falling, it’s capping your talent reach and signaling stagnation to investors and customers. Treat it as a lagging indicator: launch targeted initiatives (leadership AMAs, policy tweaks, recognition programs) and invite fresh reviews from new hires to shift sentiment upward. A 0.3‑point lift can materially expand your candidate pool within a single quarter.

Q: Can we remove negative reviews?

A: In nearly all cases, no—major platforms guard credibility by denying deletion requests except for clear policy violations like hate speech. Attempting to scrub criticism can backfire, triggering Streisand‑effect blowback and eroding trust internally. Instead, adopt a “Respond, Resolve, Reinforce” playbook.

First, respond publicly within 72 hours, thanking the reviewer and acknowledging their experience.

Second, investigate and resolve root‑cause issues, looping back with specifics where privacy allows.

Third, reinforce positive stories by encouraging balanced reviews from currently engaged employees and showcasing tangible improvements—policy changes, new benefits, leadership town‑halls—in follow‑up posts and social content.

Get Help From Talivity

Talivity helps talent teams turn their employer brand into a performance asset—anchored in strategy, delivered with bold creative, and optimized for today’s hiring funnel. Talk to our team and turn your employer brand into a hiring engine.

Leighann Emo

---

With a rich background in content development, Leighann creates engaging, educational articles that resonate with growing businesses. Her commitment to delivering informative and compelling content underscores her dedication to keeping Talivity at the forefront of thought leadership in the talent acquisition industry.